Media Watch 4 April 2025
The debunking of Rami Davidian’s fabrications by a high-profile mainstream Israeli journalist is highly significant.
But it comes a year after The Electronic Intifada concluded from its own investigations that Davidian’s self-aggrandizing accounts were replete with inconsistencies, impossibilities and lies.
Davidian, who was a star witness in Sheryl Sandberg’s 7 October atrocity propaganda film Screams Before Silence, also claimed to have seen dozens of dead victims of alleged rapes on that day, some with objects inserted into their genitals.
Raviv Drucker, a journalist with Israel’s Channel 13, revealed that his network was set to air an exposé of Davidian’s lies in the coming days.
The broadcast was, however, canceled after a promo trailing the report caused a public backlash.
“Today in the early afternoon the CEO of Channel 13, Elimiano Calemzuk, called and said that he decided not to broadcast the segment on Rami Davidian that was scheduled to be broadcast on Sunday,” Drucker revealed Friday in a post on Twitter/X.
“This was the first time that we spoke on this topic,” Drucker said. “I told him that it would be a grave error.”
“Made up from beginning to end”
Clearly upset at the suppression of his team’s work, Drucker went on to describe how meticulously the report was prepared and to characterize what it reveals about Davidian’s claims.
“These are not slight exaggerations, mildly inflating the number of those rescued, absolutely not,” Drucker wrote. “These are stories made up from beginning to end. Hair-raising stories that never, ever occurred.”
Drucker notes that Davidian’s claims of rescuing Israelis “were quoted in a reputable film, in newspapers across the world [and] in an important book.”The Electronic Intifada had already exposed Davidian’s lies almost a year ago, when it debunked Screams Before Silence – likely the “reputable film” to which Drucker refers.
The Sandberg film was promoted as “a documentary film on the sexual violence committed by Hamas,” but this writer exposed it as a total fraud on The Electronic Intifada Livestream for 1 May 2024.
The Electronic Intifada also concluded from inconsistencies in his accounts that Davidian had fabricated a superhero-like account of rescuing an Israeli woman tied to a tree by Hamas fighters.
You can watch the segments specific to Davidian in the video at the top of this page.
Making money from lies
Ever since 7 October 2023, according to Channel 13’s Drucker, Davidian “has turned his stories into an industry,” taking part in paid lecture tours in Israel and abroad, as well as fundraising campaigns.
In perhaps hundreds of interviews, Drucker wrote, Davidian “repeats over and over again, stories that simply never happened.”
Davidian’s debunked claims are also cited in a report by an all-party group of British lawmakers.
The “7 October Parliamentary Commission Report” purports to “meticulously document the grisly fates of the 1,182 people killed by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad.”
The parliamentary report cites Davidian’s stories – as told to Sandberg – as part of its “evidence,” giving his lies a veneer of official credibility.
To date, there is not a single positively identified victim, living or dead, of the alleged mass rapes on 7 October 2023.
As The Electronic Intifada has reported since the early weeks of the genocide in Gaza, Israel’s mass rape narrative is atrocity propaganda.
It is rooted in racist stereotypes of colonized and subject peoples, similar to the routinely fabricated accusations of the rape of white women used for decades to justify the lynchings of Black men across the United States.
The handful of other “eyewitnesses” to 7 October rapes or crime scenes gave accounts that collapsed completely under scrutiny, and there was a major scandal after The New York Times published a notorious December 2023 article which contained multiple debunked claims of rape.
Nor is Davidian the first grifter allegedly seeking money and fame from the mass rapes hoax.
With Drucker’s exposure of Davidian’s lies – only the latest about 7 October to be debunked – there is no excuse for Western media and politicians to keep parroting propaganda whose only purpose is to incite or attempt to justify Israel’s genocide of the Palestinian people.
Translation provided by David Sheen
Add new comment